Are countertop nugget ice makers worth it?

Nugget vs bullet vs clear ice

Bullet ice makers are usually the most affordable and fastest to make a first batch; the cubes are hollow and melt fairly quickly.

Nugget ice makers produce soft, chewable pellets that absorb flavor and are easy on teeth. They generally cost more and take more counter space.

Clear-ice makers produce harder, slower-melting cubes that suit drinks and entertaining.

How much ice do you need?

Makers are rated in pounds per day, and the bin holds only a fraction of that, because ice slowly melts back into the reservoir. If you need a lot at once for a party, start it early or move ice to the freezer as it's made.

Cleaning, noise and space

Plan to run a cleaning cycle or descale regularly, especially with hard water. Some models have self-cleaning modes.

Measure under your cabinets: some models need clearance above for the lid. Expect some fan and compressor noise while it runs.

Who they're worth it for

They're a good fit if your freezer doesn't have an ice maker, you drink a lot of iced drinks, you love nugget ice, or you host often. If you only need a few cubes a day, trays may do.

Quick checklist

• Ice type you like: nugget, bullet or clear
• Pounds per day for your household
• Height clearance under your cabinets
• Self-cleaning mode and easy-to-drain reservoir

See current prices

Live lists from our partner stores, updated hourly:

• Cheapest countertop ice makers · under $100 · under $200 · deals
• Cheapest beverage and wine fridges · under $200 · under $300 · deals

Questions